An in-depth analysis of Hemingway vs Grammarly and their proofreading and editing features, as well as their interface and pricing plans.
Hemingway vs Grammarly – Quick Comparison
| Hemingway | Grammarly | |
| Grammar checker | No | Yes |
| Plagiarism checker | No | Yes |
| Accuracy score | No | Yes |
| Readability score | Yes | Yes |
| Tone and style detection | No | Yes |
| Document uploads | Yes | Yes |
| Browser extensions | No | Yes |
| Software | Automated readability index | AI-based |
| Ease of use | High | High |
| Free trial | No | Yes |
| Business option | No | Yes |
| Affordability | Cheaper option | More expensive option |
Grammarly vs Hemingway – In-Depth Feature Comparison
As writing tools, both Grammarly and Hemingway go beyond what a built-in spellchecker can do. However, the capabilities of each differ in how they can assist a writer’s bottom line.
For example, Hemingway Editor scans your text for readability and will tell you if a sentence is too complex. Grammarly does the same and will offer suggestions for replacing or rephrasing it.
Does this mean Grammarly is better? Perhaps. Let’s see how their features and functionalities compare.
Proofreading
Spelling, grammar, punctuation, and capitalization are essential for ensuring the clarity, correctness, and overall quality of your writing. However, there are substantial differences between the Hemingway App and Grammarly in terms of how these key features work.
The Hemingway App focuses on enhancing the quality and style of your writing by analyzing your text for readability issues. It uses color-coded highlights in the text you’ve inserted to indicate issues like excessive use of adverbs, passive voice, or wordy phrases. However, Hemingway will not correct grammar, spelling, or punctuation mistakes.
Conversely, Grammarly offers an entire suite of proofreading features, including grammar, spelling, punctuation, and style. Like Hemingway, it highlights wordiness and areas where sentence structure needs improvement but goes beyond that and offers suggestions on how to improve it.
Unlike Hemingway, Grammarly flags basic grammar mistakes and gives you the correct answer. Grammarly will also detect contextual errors, such as incorrect word usage or inconsistent verb tense, and offer detailed explanations and grammar rules to help you understand and learn from your mistakes.
One proofreading area where Hemingway and Grammarly tie is the readability score. Both base it on the Flesch-Kincaid readability tests, where the higher the score, the more readable the piece.
Editing
With Hemingway Editor, users have two options; go to the website and start writing or simply copy and paste a text in the editing field. Once the text is in, the app will pinpoint issues like complex sentences, excessive adverbs, passive voice, and wordiness. The option to switch to writing mode is another plus, as it disables comments from appearing on the right side.
Our Grammarly vs Hemingway App comparison showed that, unlike Grammarly, Hemingway’s free version doesn’t require login details, saving you the hassle of having to open an account. The downside is that any changes will not be saved unless you export them to another app or use the paid version.
In contrast, both Grammarly’s free version and the paid one require you to create an account, but they will also save any edits you make. Grammarly also works across multiple platforms, and the free version is available as a browser extension, desktop app, Google Docs add-on, or on the web.
To make edits in Grammarly, you can upload a document or write in the app directly and make edits as you write. The app will underline your errors, explain why a specific sentence needs editing, and offer suggestions for improving it. A great plus here is the rephrasing feature, which tells you that a sentence needs rephrasing and does it for you.
Additionally, Grammarly allows you to customize the tone of the text based on the audience you’re targeting and the type of content you’re creating. Its continuous updates ensure that whatever you’re writing is up-to-date with language nuances and evolving writing styles.
Interface
Hemingway Editor has a clean and minimalist interface. It has an editing and writing mode, readability score, word count, and a guide to the color-coding system it uses to improve the overall flow and readability of the content. It also has a feedback and help section and a link to download the desktop version.
In contrast, Grammarly boasts a more comprehensive interface with many features. From grammar checks and punctuation errors to suggestions for enhancing vocabulary and eliminating repetitive words, Grammarly’s interface is superior to that of Hemingway. And thanks to its intuitive design, even though it’s packed with features, it’s very easy to use.For users who are often offline, the Hemingway app may be a suitable option, as once you download it on your computer, you can use it offline. Grammarly, on the other hand, is an online application that requires an internet connection to analyze your writing and offer suggestions. So for this part, choosing between Hemingway or Grammarly may be a matter of circumstances.
Grammarly vs Hemingway Pricing
Both Grammarly and Hemingway have free versions. But as with all products that have freemium pricing models, most of the advanced features are only included in the paid version.
Below you’ll find a detailed description of the pricing plans for both Grammarly and Hemingway.
Grammarly Pricing & Plans
| Plan | Cost | Features |
| Free | $0 | – Grammar, spelling, and punctuation checker – Conciseness checker – Tone detection – Auto-generated citations – Enterprise-grade privacy and security |
| Premium | $12/month | – Everything in the free plan – Spelling and punctuation consistency and English fluency – Full-sentence rewrites and formatting – Alternative word and sentence choices for variety – Tone suggestions and inclusive language – Citation style formatting and plagiarism checker |
| Business | $15/member/month | – Everything in the premium plan – Account roles and permissions and SAML single sign-on – Style guide, custom reusable snippets, brand tones, and analytics dashboard |
Hemingway Pricing & Plans
| Plan | Cost | Features |
| Hemingway Online Editor | Free | – Readability score – Highlighted readability issuesFormatting |
| Hemingway App | $19.99 (one time) | – Everything in the online editor – Offline usage – Publishing integration with Medium and WordPress – Export as TXT, MD, HTML, DOC, and PDF (with or without highlights) |
What is Better, Grammarly or Hemingway?
Grammarly is better for anyone looking for a writing assistant with powerful grammar-checking tools. It comes with an all-inclusive set of features, including vocabulary suggestions and paraphrasing, which makes it suitable for a wide range of writing styles.
Hemingway is a much cheaper alternative, fit for those only seeking to improve readability.